Skip to content

Free Shipping on Orders $50+

  • Collections
    • Bach Bash
    • Disney Vacation
    • Y2K Disney Channel
    • Custom Photo Gifts
    • Pride
    • Cruise Gifts
    • Pop Culture
  • Occasions
    • Halloween
    • Christmas
    • Valentine's Day
    • Hanukkah
    • Easter
    • Birthday
    • Bachelor/Bachelorette
    • Anniversary
    • Wedding
    • Graduation
  • Drinkware
    • Tumblers
    • Wine Glasses
    • Can Coolers
    • Shot Glasses
    • Mugs
    • Drinking Glasses
    • Water Bottles
  • Apparel
    • Shirts
    • Crewnecks
  • More!
    • Air Fresheners
    • Candles
    • Lanyards
    • Luggage Tags
    • Pet Bandanas
    • Phone Cases
    • Tote Bags
  • Reviews
Log in
    Two Crafty Gays
    • Collections
      • Bach Bash
      • Disney Vacation
      • Y2K Disney Channel
      • Custom Photo Gifts
      • Pride
      • Cruise Gifts
      • Pop Culture
    • Occasions
      • Halloween
      • Christmas
      • Valentine's Day
      • Hanukkah
      • Easter
      • Birthday
      • Bachelor/Bachelorette
      • Anniversary
      • Wedding
      • Graduation
    • Drinkware
      • Tumblers
      • Wine Glasses
      • Can Coolers
      • Shot Glasses
      • Mugs
      • Drinking Glasses
      • Water Bottles
    • Apparel
      • Shirts
      • Crewnecks
    • More!
      • Air Fresheners
      • Candles
      • Lanyards
      • Luggage Tags
      • Pet Bandanas
      • Phone Cases
      • Tote Bags
    • Reviews
    Log in Cart

    Item added to your cart

    View cart
    1. Home
    2. Accessories & More
    Filter and sort Filter

    Filter and sort

    Filter

    377 products

    Product type
    Clear
    Price

    The highest price is $25.00

    $
    $
    Clear
    Remove all
    Remove all

    377 products

    Remove all
    • Schitt's Creek Prayer Candle - Johnny image 0

      Schitt's Creek Prayer Candle - Johnny

      Schitt's Creek Prayer Candle - Johnny

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Shania Twain Prayer Candle image 0

      Shania Twain Prayer Candle

      Shania Twain Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Shawn Mendes Prayer Candle image 0

      Shawn Mendes Prayer Candle

      Shawn Mendes Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Snoop Dogg Prayer Candle image 0

      Snoop Dogg Prayer Candle

      Snoop Dogg Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Snoop Dogg Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Snoop Dogg Christmas Prayer Candle

      Snoop Dogg Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Trixie Mattel Prayer Candle image 0

      Trixie Mattel Prayer Candle

      Trixie Mattel Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Tate McRae Prayer Candle image 0

      Tate McRae Prayer Candle

      Tate McRae Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kamala Harris Prayer Candle image 0

      Kamala Harris Prayer Candle

      Kamala Harris Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kacey Musgraves Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Kacey Musgraves Christmas Prayer Candle

      Kacey Musgraves Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Katy Perry Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Katy Perry Christmas Prayer Candle

      Katy Perry Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kelly Clarkson Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Kelly Clarkson Christmas Prayer Candle

      Kelly Clarkson Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Katya Prayer Candle image 0

      Katya Prayer Candle

      Katya Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kesha Prayer Candle image 0

      Kesha Prayer Candle

      Kesha Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kim Kardashian Prayer Candle image 0

      Kim Kardashian Prayer Candle

      Kim Kardashian Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kim Petras Prayer Candle image 0

      Kim Petras Prayer Candle

      Kim Petras Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kris Jenner Prayer Candle image 0

      Kris Jenner Prayer Candle

      Kris Jenner Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Kylie Jenner Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Kylie Jenner Christmas Prayer Candle

      Kylie Jenner Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Lady Gaga Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Lady Gaga Christmas Prayer Candle

      Lady Gaga Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Lady Gaga Prayer Candle image 0

      Lady Gaga Prayer Candle

      Lady Gaga Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Lana Del Rey Prayer Candle image 0

      Lana Del Rey Prayer Candle

      Lana Del Rey Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Leslie Jordan Prayer Candle image 0

      Leslie Jordan Prayer Candle

      Leslie Jordan Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Lil Nas X Prayer Candle image 0

      Lil Nas X Prayer Candle

      Lil Nas X Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Lizzo Prayer Candle image 0

      Lizzo Prayer Candle

      Lizzo Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Madea (Tyler Perry) Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Madea (Tyler Perry) Christmas Prayer Candle

      Madea (Tyler Perry) Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Madea (Tyler Perry) Prayer Candle image 0

      Madea (Tyler Perry) Prayer Candle

      Madea (Tyler Perry) Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mariah Carey Christmas Prayer Candle image 0

      Mariah Carey Christmas Prayer Candle

      Mariah Carey Christmas Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mariah Carey Prayer Candle image 0

      Mariah Carey Prayer Candle

      Mariah Carey Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Madonna Prayer Candle image 0

      Madonna Prayer Candle

      Madonna Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Cady (Lindsay Lohan) image 0

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Cady (Lindsay Lohan)

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Cady (Lindsay Lohan)

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Regina image 0

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Regina

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Regina

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Karen image 0

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Karen

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Karen

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Gretchen image 0

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Gretchen

      Mean Girls Prayer Candle - Gretchen

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Bob Iger Prayer Candle image 0

      Bob Iger Prayer Candle

      Bob Iger Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Adele Prayer Candle image 0

      Adele Prayer Candle

      Adele Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Andrew McMahon Prayer Candle image 0

      Andrew McMahon Prayer Candle

      Andrew McMahon Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • Ariana Grande Prayer Candle image 0

      Ariana Grande Prayer Candle

      Ariana Grande Prayer Candle

      150 reviews
      Regular price From $21.00 USD
      Regular price $21.00 USD Sale price From $21.00 USD
    • 1
    • …
    • 6
    • 7
    • 8
    • 9
    • 10
    • 11

    Don't Miss the Tea...

    Get the latest gossip, glitter, and goodies—straight to your inbox (well… not that kind of straight).

    Quick links

    • Search
    Payment methods
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Diners Club
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Visa
    © 2025, Two Crafty Gays Powered by Shopify
    • Privacy policy
    • Refund policy
    • Terms of service
    • Contact information
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.
    Review picture
    Ariel

    I love my Clueless magnetic bookmark!
    Magnetic Bookmark
    Review picture
    Kristen

    This bag came out great! So cute and nice quality. Going to make a great gift.
    Disney Personalized Halloween Tote Bag - Nightmare Before Christmas
    Review picture
    Ariel

    Brandon is always so helpful! I love my custom Aaron Carter cd magnetic bookmark!
    Magnetic Bookmark
    Review picture
    kewalker89

    My 90s self is screaming! Cannot believe I found these! I’m so indecisive that it usually takes me a month or more to decide something. When I came across your store I couldn’t narrow it down. I wanted every bookmark you sold. I purchased from you in less than 5 minutes after finding you. The book marks are amazing. Bigger than I thought they would be which is even more awesome! You just made me so happy! Shipping was extremely fast. Cannot wait to use these beauties.
    Magnetic Bookmark
    Review picture
    Katlin

    I absolutely love it and love supporting small businesses! I’m 29 & this is the best case I’ve ever owned. Childhood obsession unlocked! Thanks guys 💜
    Hannah Montana iPhone Case
    ★ Reviews

    Let customers speak for us

    1239 reviews
    Write a review
    96%
    (1190)
    3%
    (35)
    1%
    (12)
    0%
    (1)
    0%
    (1)
    A
    Personalized Cruise Lanyard - Bachelorette
    Ashley

    These lanyards are perfect for our birthday cruise. Everything was easy and they had it shipped quickly. Thank you so much!

    A
    Disney Personalized Halloween Tote Bag - Nightmare Before Christmas
    Alexis M.

    The item was just like it’s pictured

    A
    Disney Cruise Line Personalized Christmas Luggage Tag - Inside Out
    April

    These are well made, adorable and perfect for our upcoming vacation!

    A
    Magnetic Bookmark
    Ariel

    I love my Clueless magnetic bookmark!

    User picture
    l
    Royal Caribbean Personalized Luggage Tag
    lisawinkelbauer1

    I ordered these as a gift for my daughter. They are adorable, as advertised. The price was right and they arrived super fast! I highly recommend this item and this Shop.

    123